ADVERTISEMENT in the Lexington Leader for Weldon Sowards “World War Poems.” (Photo provided)

By Cheri Daniels
Local History Librarian, 
Woodford County Library

When taking inventory of the Woodford County Library’s History Room, we discovered three copies of a small bound book, with gilded lettering, published in 1912: Delusions of Democracy by M. Weldon Sowards of Versailles. 


The author was a Georgetown native, but a resident of Versailles for over 25 years. He wrote this book while he was employed as a mail clerk for the L&N Railroad. 
Just prior to the title’s release, The Woodford Sun reported on Sowards’ plans for imminent publication, stating that over 200 copies had been pre-sold under the title Illusions of Democracy. It was also advertised as a non-partisan work that examined various forms of democracy throughout world history. 


While a neutral narrative was his goal, Sowards did not hesitate to give his opinions regarding the state of politics in 1912. He was very anti-(Theodore) Roosevelt, and lamented the loss of the Whig Party because it failed to address the issue of slavery in a strong or timely manner – which gave rise to the Republican Party. 
But most of his historical assessment focused on the reasons behind democracy’s failure throughout history. In his conclusion, which also attempted to explain America’s precarious political state in 1912, he summed up our problems and hinted at the possibility of a governing utopia:


“While the triumph of radical socialism should be deplored, yet the conduct of the two great political parties, their monumental blunders, their venality and their subjection to corporate influences and the special interests are hastening the realization of those monstrous doctrines. The salvation of the country demands the divorce of the government from corporate power and other sinister influences, the elimination of all lobbyists from our legislative halls…The electorate purged, vice dethroned…the dawn of a glorious era would appear, and the dreams of the philosophers and seers since the foundation of the world would be realized in a genuine republic….” 
Once the title was published, Aitcheson A. Bowmar, co-publisher and editor of The Woodford Sun, gave it a hearty review, except for a few points: 


“The book is very entertaining and well-written and shows extensive reading and wide information. Mr. Sowards’ contention is that Simon-pure democracy has never existed and cannot exist, and that republics have always been short-lived, the reason for both facts being that the mass of mankind are unfit to govern themselves. Believing universal suffrage to be a failure, but being a believer in a republican form of government, he advocates restricting the suffrage by barring out the illiterates and imposing upon electors a property qualification of at least $1,000. Most thinking men will agree with Mr. Sowards as to his first remedy – barring out illiterates. I certainly do. From his second remedy – a property qualification – I dissent most violently. Many men with less than $1,000 possess more character and more intelligence than many of those who exceed that sum…. The test of good citizenship is not a man’s power to accumulate worldly goods. To wrench the franchise from every man without property would be to step backward into the dark, and to restore to the seigneurs of some future day that power of ‘high and low justice’ which it cost so much blood to take away from them.” 


If we look at the time period that birthed these opinions, the United States was drawing to a close the unencumbered wealth of the Gilded Age and industrial explosion that allowed “robber barons” to rise in power. Sowards included this group by description, despite being employed by the railroads – home to some of the most prominent leaders of this class. 


Other influences to note: women had not yet achieved the vote, and Jim Crow laws were consistently removing and/or preventing African-Americans from the basic rights of a free society. It is ironic that Sowards was fighting against the injustices he perceived from the abuse of power perpetrated by those with extreme wealth, while also arguing that the uneducated should be excluded altogether from suffrage. Sowards considered himself an educated man, having attended Vanderbilt University in his younger years.
The other issue breathing down everyone’s neck was the threat of war, which broke out two years later in 1914. 


World War I changed Sowards’ tune quite a bit. As a result, he published a collection of World War Poems in 1918. While he continued to lament the lack of true democracy in the world, he was quite willing to use this new work to extol the wisdom of Woodrow Wilson and eviscerate the “Hun (German).” Clearly, he understood the threat WWI brought to the freedoms he already enjoyed in the United States. 


This work of poetry was extolled by the Lexington Leader, which declared Sowards to be the “Poet Laureate of Uncle Sam’s Mail Service.” Despite Sowards’ earlier criticisms of the American political system in his previous work, this book of poetry included many patriotic poems about the glories of the American Flag. 


For someone who was convinced that our democratic republic was mere folly, and doomed to extinction at some point in the future, a World War brought American virtues more into focus, as evidenced by his romantic poetry about the glories of his native land. 
Attempting to uncover Moses Weldon Sowards’ own political affiliation was quite a challenge. According to newspaper accounts between 1880 and 1940, he waffled between both parties. He was consistently politically active and was mentioned in several news stories due to his fiery speeches – sometimes at Democratic rallies and sometimes at Republican rallies. 


In 1888, the Georgetown News reported that Sowards had “Quit the Grand Old Party” to join the Owens Democratic Club. This switch was a mere three months after he and a few others traveled to Louisville as delegates to the Republican State Convention.
Despite being reassigned away from Versailles several times for railroad duties, even to Cincinnati for a decade, Sowards never lost his love for Woodford County. 


In 1919, The Woodford Sun published Sowards’ eloquent letter that he included with his subscription: “Messrs. A. and D. Bowmar, Editors – As I am now a resident of Ashland, will you kindly send me the Sun for a year? I don’t want the earth – only the Sun. I cannot do without it. I shall ever be interested in the welfare of the people of Versailles and Woodford County. I shall always love those good people who were my friends and neighbors so long and were so kind and loving to my dear, lamented wife and daughter, whose memory is so precious to me. To those noble, whole-souled people I want to express my deepest gratitude and to wish them long life and happiness.” 

Local History Librarian Cheri Daniels, who runs the Woodford County Library’s History Room, writes a quarterly article she draws from the library’s archives for the Sun. As usual, this is a fascinating story – particularly since our “Clippings from the Past” this past year has included both the start of America’s involvement in World War I and the end of that war.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *